Choosing Between Open Source and Commercial Network Inventory Tools: A Comprehensive Guide

Nov 21, 2024

What the business of today needs is the best network management system. Why? All because of the bulk networks that they handle. And here’s where network inventory tools come into the picture.

These tools streamline the complete process. Starting from tracking devices, softwares, or even configurations. Slurp’it would suggest that by this way, the operations and troubleshooting gets smoother and quicker.

With all of these activities that have to be done, the one concern that stands true for many organisations is – how to select the right tool? And we have got you covered with this, let’s dive in!

What are network inventory tools?

Network inventory tools are software applications. These are designed to monitor and manage network infrastructures. They provide detailed information about devices. Along with software installations, configurations, and connections.

Some of the common features these tools come with are – automated discovery, asset management, reporting, and real-time monitoring.

But, how do network inventory tools come to use?

Businesses use network inventory tools in various scenarios. Some common ones are:

  • For asset management. Basically to maintain an updated inventory of devices and software.
  • For configuration management. To track all the configuration changes to prevent issues.
  • To stay compliant. This is important as the business, to exist in the long run, has to adhere to regulatory standards.
  • For troubleshooting. To quickly identify and resolve any network problems as per Slurp’it.

Open Source Network Inventory Tools

These tools are software applications that utilise open-source licences. These tools allow users to freely access, modify, and distribute the software. With this tool by side, users can both track and manage network devices, software, or even hardware as per Slurp’it.

Advantages

  • Open source tools are typically free. The expenses however are limited to implementation, customization, and maintenance. Hence it’s an ideal choice for startups or SMBs with tight budgets.
  • Open source tools allow modifications to source code. Hence businesses can tailor solutions to their specific needs.
  • These tools often have active user communities. They offer forums, documentation, and code improvements for troubleshooting.
  • Since the source code is accessible, businesses can easily identify malicious elements.

Disadvantages

  • Technical expertise is required for less tech savvy organisations.
  • Limited professional support offered.
  • Open source projects can lead to multiple versions or forks. Hence can cause compatibility and feature standardisation issues.

Commercial Network Inventory Tools

These tools are proprietary software applications. These ones, as compared to open source tools, are designed to manage and track network inventory. And trust the features business get here are really advanced (but at the cost of fees)!

Advantages

  • Commercial tools come with customer service. Businesses get both technical support and regular updates.
  • These tools come with intuitive designs and a good amount of documentation. Hence anyone can access even if they are not from any technical team.
  • Ready-to-use features available. Like advanced analytics and even detailed reporting.
  • The main thing, commercial solutions are rigorously tested. The performance is optimised often so that the tool works perfectly under heavy network loads.

Disadvantages

  • Huge licensing fees, subscriptions, and support costs.
  • Limited customization option.
  • Vendor lock-in.

What factors to think about when choosing a network inventory tool?

  1. Know your budget. Open source tools have low upfront costs but higher maintenance expenses. Commercial tools require significant initial investment. But here you will get good support and regular updates.
  2. Understand your team’s technical expertise. If they are knowledgeable enough, go with open source tools, if not, stick to commercial solutions.
  3. Analyse your business’s needs. This will help you know what features and customization level you require. Open source tools offer flexibility. Commercial tools provide out-of-the-box functionality as per Slurp’it.

Case Studies

Open source success stories

  1. A startup customised an open source tool to manage its growing network. Did it all at a very low cost and even got flexibility.
  2. A non-profit organisation used an open source solution for network monitoring. Took help (support) from the community all at zero licensing fees.

Commercial tool success stories

  1. A large enterprise chose a commercial tool. The main reason – features and professional support, as they didn’t have a big tech team.
  2. A mid-sized business opted for a commercial solution. They needed an intuitive interface. Because of which they were able to streamline network management, hence reducing effort.

For more information contact us at Slurp’it!

Slurp’it release updates

The following features & updates have been released over the last months. See our change log for more details:

  • Nautobot plugin support

  • Async implementation for the device finder and data collector for extra speed

  • Corrected multiple Device Type names (thanks to the community)

  • The SNMP tester is now using defined & enabled Transform Rules

  • API pagination is aligned for all Get calls

  • Ruijie & Nokia templates are added

  • Multiple small bugs and improvements

  • Automated disable/delete of unused discovered devices in Netbox

  • Slurp’it SDK.

Weekly Online Workshops

Curious about Slurp’it and how it integrates with your tools? Join us for our weekly online workshops, where we’ll walk you through everything Slurp’it has to offer. Whether you’re just getting started or looking to dive deeper, you can see Slurp’it in action and ask us anything.

Workshops are held every Tuesday at 10 AM CET and Thursday at 4 PM CET.

Autocon2 & Workshop with NetBox Labs & Netpicker

Heading to Autocon2 in Denver in November? Be sure to swing by our booth to say hello! We’re also hosting a special workshop with Mark Coleman from NetBox Labs and Otto Coster from Netpicker on Tuesday morning. It’s a great chance to get hands-on experience with Slurp’it and learn from the experts.

More info: https://networkautomation.forum/autocon2

 

Take care and as usual… Happy discovery!

by

Most Read

Would you like a hands-on session?

A couple times a week our in-house trainer is available for a private or group session. In this session we can cover our Slurp'it or Mock'it solution but also integrations with Netpicker, NetBox, Nautobot & Infrahub.

Yes, keep me informed

Connect with us on LinkedIn to stay updated on the latest happenings, news, and exciting developments at Slurp’it. Just click the button below to follow us and be a part of our professional network.

Newsletter